How a fragmented internet is reshaping Gen Z marketing
different strokes for different folks
TikTok? Pinterest? Reddit? In our era of AI search engines and algorithmic feeds, social media has become intensely personal and wildly scattered. With audiences now splintering, how can marketers hope to reach Gen Z?
Social media marketing has come a long way since the prehistoric days of 2010.
Back then, brands were still finding their footing when it came to online advertising, often clumsily announcing a new product or campaign through dusty corporate speak that failed to understand the strengths of platforms like Twitter and Facebook. Content was posted in a uniform, wholesale manner, with copy or video distributed identically across different websites with little consideration for the nuances each one required. At the time, these spaces were driven solely by the information that our friends and real humans (yes, imagine) shared, serving as even playing grounds for everyone.
Fast forward to today, and things look very different.
The emergence of AI, as well as a shift toward algorithmic feeds, means that social media is no longer simply about our friends. Content creators and automated posts are now the primary drivers of online engagement, leading to the emergence of entire industries that utilise each platform’s metrics as best they can. What do we mean by this? Think stealth marketing, where agencies pay anonymous accounts to share content on specific platforms to steer public discourse on everything from pop stars to electoral fraud. If we’re thinking further back, you can also lump SEO marketing agencies in there too, alongside newer variations of the same business model that offer AI prompt advice.
As Gen Z has grown up with these online spaces, they’ve separated their intentions and moods onto different platforms. Each one carries its own vibe, language changes, and usage, which means that brands can no longer create marketing campaigns that look identical (or even similar, frankly) across each space.
Advertisers are having to actively optimise their potential for discovery across different ecosystems, rather than tailoring copy and visuals to a singular search engine. Gone are the days of everyone turning to Google. Instead, searches are scattered across various websites, like Reddit, LinkedIn, and even Pinterest. ChatGPT especially has upended traditional SEO, as copywriters now have to consider the best ways to ensure that their content will be pulled as referencing material, which is a whole lot more complicated than the tried-and-true pillars of keywords, hyperlinking, and calls to action.
Community is beginning to dwarf reach, too. Hitting a large number of viewers or attempting to connect with the masses is far less of a priority in 2026, as this often doesn’t convert to meaningful engagement or sales. Greater emphasis is starting to be placed on smaller, more niche collections of users, where trust is greater and conversion rates are likely to be higher. Instead of finding ways to interrupt consumers, brands are now asking how they can become part of a broader cultural conversation that permeates traditional advertising. Context is key here.
So, what’s the takeaway?
Put simply, marketers hoping to reach Gen Z must consider the differences between each website or app they’re engaging with, and should rethink their key performance indicators. Rather than simply ballooning engagement numbers as much as possible, brands should dig deeper and explore how their metrics are serving them in real time. One million short-form views via TikTok will be far less impactful than, say, 1,500 shares on Instagram. Similarly, your brand being a sponsor or topic of discussion on a niche podcast is far more likely to convert to meaningful spending power, as it recognises and respects a specific community.
Gen Z’s internet and social media use is completely fragmented. Mainstream and monolithic culture is largely falling to the sidelines, and successful marketing must get to grips with the complexities this brings with it.
See also:
🌍 Gen Z around the Web
the latest stories in youth culture and changing trends…
Rightwing Gen Z women are celebrating the anti-trans Supreme Court ruling (the guardian)
A court ruling this week upheld state restrictions on transgender students’ sports participation. On the steps of the US Supreme Court, conservative Gen Z women were celebrating, declaring that the government agreed with their belief that ‘a man cannot be a woman.’ This piece examines the young women who are at the centre of the MAGA movement in the US, as they reshape the Republican stereotypes of old white men into trendy, youth-led movements. Could this be the future of MAGA once Trump is gone? Read more
Why Gen Z is suddenly obsessed with bird-watching (country living)
Now, take this one with a pinch of salt, considering the data comes from the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, but a new survey suggests that nearly 750,000 16- to 19-year-olds in the UK bird-watch regularly, a staggering 1,088 percent increase since 2018. Where has all that enthusiasm come from, you might be wondering? The pandemic seems to be a leading factor, as young Gen Zers were forced to stay home during a very formative period of their lives. Bird-watching provided something to do, and that experience could easily be shared online. Read more
Why Gen Z are planning for life without a state pension (bbc)
Up to half of Gen Z believe that a state pension won’t exist by the time they retire. With more young people uninterested in having children, and with an ageing population that could become top-heavy in the coming decades, fewer Gen Zers have faith that any kind of government-regulated retirement fund will be possible. Almost half of working-age adults aren’t paying into a private pension pot either, which could mean a looming crisis. Still, climate change might have displaced us all by then, so does it really matter in the grand scheme of things? Read more
‘This bargain is eroding’: inside the youngest generations’ view of the American Dream (cnbc)
The idea that you can ‘play by the rules’ and economically prosper was once a guaranteed certainty for younger people, especially during the 1960s, 70s, and 80s, at least in the US. Fast forward to today, and Gen Z has had a particularly hard entry into adulthood, with flailing job markets, high costs of living, and mountains of debt. These pressures have eroded the idea of an ‘American Dream,’ and the traditional U-shaped curve of happiness throughout life has now flattened, as young people become increasingly distressed as they age. What can the US do to try to alleviate things for Gen Zers? Read more
Gen Z didn’t kill cinema, beer, or soda. Tired marketing did (the drum)
We’ve had a scan of this article, and we’re confident that some - if not most of it - was probably written by AI, at least in its early draft. Still, despite ChatGPT likely being the main author here, the points this article makes are too important to pass up on. With the highly-coveted success of Obsession, Marty Supreme, and The Backrooms, it’s obvious that young people are looking for something fresh and innovative to get stuck into, rather than a rehash of traditional media that they’ve seen a million times. The recent, disappointing opening to Supergirl is evidence to support this theory, and suggests that the old guard might have to rethink their strategies across many different industries if they want to capture modern audiences. Read more
That’s all for this week! Make sure to subscribe for the latest on Gen Z and youth culture, and check out The Common Thred for a weekly roundup of the latest news, trends, and thought pieces.
With the speed at which social media moves it's definitely hard for brands to keep on track of how best to reach audiences. It's why we prioritise being in culture. That way we can help the brands we work with communicate the things people actually care about!