Were we wrong about Marty Supreme?
we’re feeling like Marty right about now
A few months ago, we heralded A24 for its viral, Gen Z-focused marketing. Now, only two months later, Timothee Chalamet has fallen out of public favour, and Marty Supreme has lost nearly every award at all major shows, including the Oscars. What happened?
Well, the Oscars came and went…and Marty Supreme picked up zero awards.
It follows on from a largely unsuccessful awards run across the board, with the film missing out on all eleven BAFTAs in February, making it tied for the most losses in the ceremony’s history. Lead actor Timothee Chalamet did manage to bag Best Actor at the Golden Globes, but the overriding public sentiment has been that the movie mostly flopped. Only two months ago, all signs indicated that A24’s table tennis flick was to dominate critics and voters. We even lauded the film’s marketing, describing it as a ‘trailblazing’ moment for modern advertising.
So, what happened?
Despite the blimps, the clever pseudo-marketing meetings, and the streetwear jacket drops, it seems that audiences eventually found Marty Supreme’s advertising campaign to be gimmicky and overreaching. Chalamet was absolutely everywhere, appearing on talk shows and dropping into music videos, constantly promoting the film with a mix of his real personality and Marty’s. While it appeared to be effective at first, it ran out of momentum throughout February, with Sinners picking up steam as the big award shows loomed.
Chalamet has also been in hot water over the past few weeks for saying that ‘no one cares’ about ballet or opera as performative arts. The backlash, coupled with the sheer oversaturation of Chalamet in popular media, has turned large swathes of his audience away, leaving Marty Supreme in a compromised position. The Hollywood Reporter is calling for a ‘Chalamet Break,’ while The New York Times has claimed that even his most diehard supporter, who runs ‘Club Chalamet,’ is temporarily going offline.
What does Marty Supreme’s hero-to-villain arc say about Gen Z marketing?
While the context behind the run-up to award shows is always complex, the absolute crash out in public favour over the last few months indicates that Gen Z’s appetite and retention for marketing campaigns are extremely fleeting. Where it initially felt unique and novel, Marty Supreme’s gimmicky approach steadily started to come across as a spectacle that lacked authenticity. It is crucial to convey genuineness when trying to appeal to Gen Z; the moment it feels meticulously orchestrated, you’ll start to lose them as an audience.
Marty Supreme essentially became a victim of its own hype. Online attention and trends are notoriously fast-moving, and audiences quickly shift to the next cultural moment as soon as it arrives. It certainly doesn’t help that Chalamet has been divisive and outspoken over the past month or so, either, and narratives can completely flip if any mistake is made. As we said in January, Marty Supreme was poised to win big, but Chalamet and A24 may have been too aggressive, ultimately leading to viewer fatigue and audience division.
The controversy surrounding Chalamet - his ballet comments, relationship with Kylie Jenner, lack of awards, and overly confident demeanour - has also weakened his relatability to the average twentysomething. We know that Gen Z have strong parasocial relationships with celebrity figures, typically forming intense online fandoms that bring lofty expectations. As soon as Chalamet began to falter and move away from his ‘soft boy’ and ‘arty’ image, he lost a significant amount of traction with his audience.
The lesson to take from this story isn’t clear, at least not yet. What we do know, however, is that social media marketing and industry buzz don’t always translate to award success and critical praise, no matter how faultproof it may seem at first. This is true for both film and music, with Jack Harlow - a rapper once seen as the next big thing - currently being clowned on all over social media for his latest album and recent comments made on several podcasts.
Social media is brutal and flippant. Even when you think you’ve won the world over, it can just as easily come back to bite you.
See also:
🌍 Gen Z around the Web
the latest stories in youth culture and changing trends…
Gen Z thinks capital letters are just ‘too intense,’ and a linguist agrees (upworthy)
Have you noticed that Gen Z tend to avoid using capital letters? Whether it’s texting, YouTube video titles, or captions on short-form content like TikTok, the reluctance to use correct grammar is widespread among young people. What gives? Research suggests that Gen Z find using capital letters to be formal and intense. This article provides further insight from an expert who can break it down much better than we can. Read more
Gen Z are turning their backs on social media (except for TikTok) (independent)
A new poll has found that a big majority of Gen Zers are pulling back from social media, with more of us looking to improve our physical health, foster real-world connections, and ultimately ditch the endless algorithms of doom. However, despite an intention to quit, a big chunk of young people still use TikTok daily or weekly, suggesting that it might be hard to correct course. Read more
Social media is teaching Gen Z to hate the skin they’re in (the globe and mail)
As most of us are probably aware by now, social media often encourages dissatisfaction toward our appearance and personal style, prompting algorithms to churn out targeted adverts that sell us products we probably don’t need. The skin care industry is thriving under this business model, as Gen Z grapple with a new, growing anti-aging trend known as ‘prejuvenation.’ This is where young people feel pressure to treat signs of aging before they’ve even appeared. Read more
Gen Z says hitting this age officially makes you old (vice)
Speaking of being obsessed with the passage of time, a new survey has shed some light on when Gen Z thinks ‘old age’ starts. According to the poll, organised by ‘Age Without Limits,’ Gen Z believe that 62 is the first year of being a true senior citizen. They also believe that people stop looking good in current fashion at 56, start to struggle with technology at 59, and show signs of cognitive decline at 62. Read more
Can this gadget curb Gen Z’s phone addiction? I tested it myself (the times)
How can young people successfully get away from their phone screens? In our age of social media addiction, tech companies the world over are doing their best to tap into a potentially lucrative market, offering up gimmicky products to ‘help’ lower screen time. This reporter tests out the new ‘Brick,’ a plastic accessory that locks apps remotely away from your device. The results? Mixed, to say the least. Read more
📚 Substack’ed picks of the Week
Our top Gen Z substack posts…
Privacy is the sexiest thing you can have in 2026 (unfiltered and free)
Contemplating our own social media behaviours and lack of privacy can be a tough pill to swallow, especially for Gen Z. They’ve grown up with digital oversharing being the norm, and reestablishing boundaries can feel like an uphill battle. This piece by @itsnata gives some insight into our relationship with the internet and our sense of self, as well as tips to help you keep your private life…well, private. Read more
Offline is the new luxury (carmin amor)
Occupying a space that isn’t always online has become a privilege in the modern era, a topic we covered ourselves a few weeks ago. This piece by @nicte takes a further dive into influencers and the scary world of digital spaces, considering the future of our social media use and the implications on wider society. Might we see a generational shift and a genuine move toward all things analogue? Read more
Be delusional about your potential (over my years)
In need of some motivation as we head into the weekend? This post by @fatimanotes provides a great boost for our self-confidence, encouraging us all to feel a little deluded about our own dreams. Progress doesn’t come without sacrifice and significant effort. Will we fail? Maybe, but we also tried. Which is the most important thing after everything is said and done. Read more
That’s all for this week! Make sure to subscribe for the latest on Gen Z and youth culture, and check out The Common Thred for a weekly roundup of the latest news, trends, and thought pieces.
Thank you for mentioning me 🩷🙆🏻♀️